Wholesale cookie butter for your store

Top products in cookie butter

Stock the products that set you apart

Shop over 100,000 brands on Faire, with data-backed recommendations as unique as your store.

Unlock wholesale pricing

Nut Butter

See all

Flavored Syrup

See all

All products in cookie butter

Bestseller

Edible Cookie Dough! Chocolate Chip | Set of 12

Red Velvet NYC

5.0 (11)

Unlock wholesale price

Cookie Butter Cheesecake in a Jar – Creamy Cheesecake & Crunchy Cookie Spread

Oh! Crema

Unlock wholesale price

Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter 17.6 lb tub

Sweet As Fudge Candy Shoppe

5.0 (90)

Unlock wholesale price

New

12 oz Date Cashew Cookie Dough Nut Butter

Ground Up

5.0 (60)

Unlock wholesale price

12 Units FREEBIE- Topical Wellness Best Sellers

Magnum Solace

5.0 (347)

Unlock wholesale price

We're NutZ Sumore Peanut Butter

UPSCALE FREEZE

4.8 (162)

Unlock wholesale price

Classic Peanut Butter Cookie 8 count box

Amish Country Snacks

5.0 (5)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

9 lb PISTACHIO CREAM, 20% pistachio, Dubai chocolate pistachio cream

Diana's Delights LLC

5.0 (15)

Unlock wholesale price

Creamed Honey 12 Pack - Single Flavor Selection

Nate's Nectar

4.9 (207)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Mint Cookies and Cream (10-Pack)

Stars + Honey

4.8 (80)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Organic Peanut Butter

BUDDY BUDDY

5.0 (9)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

STUFFED: S'mores

My Big Fat Cookie

4.8 (127)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Chocolate Hazelnut Butter Spread

FINE & RAW

4.9 (265)

Unlock wholesale price

Biscoff Cookie Butter Squares

I’d Rather Bake

Unlock wholesale price

Sugar Cookie with Buttercream Icing 2.25oz

C. Krueger's

4.9 (33)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Cookies And Cream

My Big Fat Cookie

4.8 (127)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Cookie Dough Granola - 6/10 OZ

Oat Haus

5.0 (48)

Unlock wholesale price

Coop's Peanut Butter Sauce

Coop's

5.0 (44)

Unlock wholesale price

Biscoff Cookie Butter Spread - Peanut Butter Alternative - Crunchy - 13.4 Oz - Case Of 8

Ware Spark

3.5 (13)

Unlock wholesale price

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie

3 sizes

Blindspot Nutbutters

4.3 (9)

Unlock wholesale price

Cookie Butter Brownie

Cora’s Cakery

3.7 (3)

Unlock wholesale price

Nutella B-Ready Crispy Wafers, 0.7 oz, 36 ct

Swift Trade Group LLC

4.0 (11)

Unlock wholesale price

Brown Butter Cookie, Bite Sized Snack Pack - 1 oz

Unna Bakery

4.9 (59)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Vanilla Cookie Granola Butter | Nut-free, Vegan, GF Spread

Oat Haus

5.0 (48)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Lemon Cookie Cashew & Coconut Butter

Big Spoon Roasters

5.0 (217)

Unlock wholesale price

Pistachio Coconut Cookie Butter - Cookie Inspired, Natural

MoonButter Co

Unlock wholesale price

Cookie Butter Cashew Butter: Vegan, Gluten Free

Elavi

5.0 (12)

Unlock wholesale price

FILLING BISCO CREAM BISCOFF (PAIL) - CHOCOLAKE

Hudson Meat Company

3.7 (41)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Maple & Cinnamon

Churn Foods

5.0 (3)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Peanut Butter Persuasion Cookie

Alternative Baking Company

4.9 (79)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Get in My Belly, PB & Jelly

TRUBAR

4.8 (66)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Classic Browned Butter Chocolate Chip

big fat cookie, llc

5.0 (8)

Unlock wholesale price

Syruvia Syrup Pump For 750ml Syrup Bottle (Pack of 12)

Syruvia

4.9 (103)

Unlock wholesale price

New

Cookie Butter Protein Cookies | Box of 10

ChunkyFit Protein Snacks

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

S’mores

The Crispery

5.0 (540)

Unlock wholesale price

Cookie Date Spread

Wanna Date?

4.5 (11)

Unlock wholesale price

Cookie Butter High Protein Peanut Butter Spread

Nuts 'N More

4.9 (8)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Butter Pecan Meltaways 32 oz. tin

David's Cookies

4.8 (15)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Sugar Free Cookie Dough Syrup

Jordan's Skinny Mixes

4.8 (1,649)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Creamy Pistachio Spread

Pistakio

4.9 (55)

Unlock wholesale price

Peanut Butter Cookie with Fudge Icing 2.25oz

C. Krueger's

4.9 (33)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Buji Brown Butter Stick

Buji Brown Butter

5.0 (7)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

STUFFED: Peanut Butter Cream

My Big Fat Cookie

4.8 (127)

Unlock wholesale price

Cookie Dough Bites

Candy Club

4.9 (2,330)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

toasted marshmallow

surrup.

4.9 (11)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

Moonstruck Dubai-Style Chocolate (Fair Trade Certified)

Moonstruck Chocolate Co

4.9 (238)

Unlock wholesale price

Bestseller

cinnamon danish

Reisman's Bakery

4.8 (48)

Unlock wholesale price

Choco White Spread

GOOD GOOD

Unlock wholesale price

…

Shop tasty cookie butter ideas

Discover gourmet treat artisans

Try something new! Free returns on all opening orders.

Magnum Solace

5.0 (347)

“Products look great and are packaged well. Shipping was fast. Thank you!”

Madeleine (Pendleton, OR, United States)

Ground Up

5.0 (60)

“all is GOOD! Thank you!”

Ralph (Seattle, WA, United States)

Oat Haus

5.0 (48)

“Oat Haus granola butters check all of our boxes - great taste, quality ingredients, and looks cute on our shelves! We have been a long time repurchaser and we look forward to a continued partnership in the future! 10/10 recommend.”

Koral (Phoenix, AZ, United States)

Pistakio

4.9 (55)

“The customer service was amazing they went above and beyond to send me the correct product and even sent me extra. I will be a lifelong customer!”

Leah (Flint, MI, United States)

UPSCALE FREEZE

4.8 (162)

“I love the mystery mochie bag and know my customers will love them. I have loved everything I have ordered from them. Thank you”

Kim (Hartland, WI, United States)

Big Spoon Roasters

5.0 (217)

“These bars and nut butters are so incredible. Our clients are loving them. My business partner is so obsessed that she has to limit herself to one a day. The first couple of days she got a little out of control. Since we are a fitness studio, we did have to run samples of the bars since they are not marketed as a protein bar but our clients love them!”

Devin (Oklahoma City, OK, United States)