My Big Fat Cookie wholesale
Top Shop
To earn Top Shop status, brands must:
Earn a 4.8+ rating over the last 12 months
Fulfill orders quickly & smoothly
Run a world-class shop page
Maintain a fresh catalog
·
·
Calverton, NY
Delivers by May 28-Jun 8
About My Big Fat Cookie
Hello! At My Big Fat Cookie, we take pride in not just delivering exceptional baked goods but also providing an unmatched experience that sets us apart in the industry. We take pride in crafting every single cookie, brownie, bread and marshmallowey treat from scratch, using our own original recipes and quality ingredients. When we say "homemade," we mean it—because nothing leaves our kitchen that isn't baked by us. Be aware that not all brands follow this same commitment to authenticity. We believe in transparency and real homemade goodness, and we think our customers deserve the same. Don't settle for anything less than the true taste of a homemade/handmade treat from My Big Fat Cookie! So go ahead and "Treat your palate" to premium ingredients and taste the difference! Your customers will thank you!
Continue exploring
Discover the full catalog and unlock wholesale pricing with My Big Fat Cookie and thousands of brands on Faire.
TRUSTED BY HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF RETAILERS
“If you aren’t using Faire, you’re missing a great
opportunity. Start today and deal with a very professional
company helping all shopkeepers buy quality products
from independent makers and artisans.”
Cindy Davenport, Cinport Floral Studio & Gift Designs by Cinport
Ratings and reviews
Relevance
Top Shop celebrates exceptional brands who have earned a 4.8+ rating over the last 12 months, fulfill orders quickly and smoothly, and maintain a fresh catalog.
4.8
Brand rating (125 reviews)
5
112
4
7
3
2
2
2
1
2
4.8
Product quality
4.9
Fulfillment
4.9
Communication
Purchased to host my brokerage open house and these were a hit.
Purchased to host my brokerage open house and these were a hit.
May 22, 2026 • Lolita • Fort Washington, MD, United States
Purchased products:
The cookies arrived on time, were packaged very well, and seem to be of excellent quality. They are large, heavy, and feel like a premium product.
The cookies arrived on time, were packaged very well, and seem to be of excellent quality. They are large, heavy, and feel like a premium product.
May 22, 2026 • Rhoda • Cedar Park, TX, United States
Purchased products:
Not happy that the sell by date on one of the cookies is less than a month and then the s’mores ones came a big gooey mess when it says that the marshmallow is between the two when it’s all over the whole entire container
Not happy that the sell by date on one of the cookies is less than a month and then the s’mores ones came a big gooey mess when it says that the marshmallow is between the two when it’s all over the whole entire container
May 13, 2026 • Tera • West Winfield, NY, United States
Purchased products:
Hello! Thank you for bringing this to our attention. With regards to the sell by date, all of our sell by information is available under each product for all to read which includes additional ways to store the cookies to prolong the shelf life. As for the S'mores, please feel free to contact us directly whenever you have questions or a product is not what was advertised so that we can make it right. —My Big Fat Cookie • May 13, 2026
Hello! Thank you for bringing this to our attention. With regards to the sell by date, all of our sell by information is available under each product for all to read which includes additional ways to store the cookies to prolong the shelf life. As for the S'mores, please feel free to contact us directly whenever you have questions or a product is not what was advertised so that we can make it right. —My Big Fat Cookie • May 13, 2026
Great product, high sell ability! Great customer service! The cookie butter cookies were awesome sellers for us!
Great product, high sell ability! Great customer service! The cookie butter cookies were awesome sellers for us!
May 8, 2026 • Haley • Melvin, IA, United States
Purchased products:
Taste great
Taste great
May 8, 2026 • Mary • Elberton, GA, United States
Purchased products:
Ready to start buying wholesale online?
60-day payment terms
Free returns on all opening orders
Unique products curated for your store