The flavors of fall are perfectly captured in our Pumpkin Butter. It has often been described as tasting similar to pumpkin pie, but without the cream or eggs. The flavor is rich with the subtle taste of lemon enhanced by spices including cinnamon, ginger, and cloves.  It is delicious served on toast, scones, pancakes, in yogurt or served over ice cream. Be sure to check out our original recipes for Cookie Dip and Pumpkin Vinaigrette. 9 oz. size. Pumpkin Butter returns in mid-late August and sells out by the end of the year. You will want a couple extra jars to indulge in all season long! Fruit butters are slow-cooked, sweetened-and-spiced smooth spreads. Its name comes from the fact that it spreads smoothly on toast, biscuits, scones, or pancakes in place of butter.